26 June 2010


Philosophy and Religion, Part 2a


Johannesburg, 2010

The Communist University’s system is not in good shape as this post goes out.

Please do not reply to this message if you receive it by e-mail. Please do not post e-mail at all to the CU group for the moment. (It is safe to comment on the blog, however.)

This is because Google has blocked access to the group. Hence I am not able to subscribe or unsubscribe people, or to deal with pending unmoderated messages. This situation should sort itself out in a day or two. I have communicated to Google. The sudden unexpected increase in e-mail traffic on Friday set off an automatic precaution, which now has to be reversed by human intervention, which will take time. After that, all requests will be attended to.

So please assist by not posting at this time.

Johannesburg, 2004

The Communist University started in June, 2003, fully seven years ago. The main text linked below was prepared for the CU when it was six months old. It is an attempt to walk through the history of philosophy using the problematic of the individual versus society as the binding dialectical theme. As well as a chronicle of philosophical thought it includes a diagram that traces the present-day contending schools back to a split that took place around where Marx and Engels come into the picture. That great parting of the ways was marked by a specific set of circumstances, which is worth describing and referencing, so this is what I will try to do today, below.

Berlin, 1841

Hegel died in November, 1831, when Karl Marx was 13 and Frederick Engels 11. Ten years later, Marx graduated from the University of Berlin and was awarded a doctorate of philosophy by the University of Jena shortly before his 24th birthday. Also in 1841, Engels was sent to Berlin to spend a year with the Artillery Guards. There is no record of Marx and Engels meeting in Berlin at this time. Their first recorded meeting was in Cologne, in November, 1842. Marx was editing a magazine called the Rheinische Zeitung (it was his first job) while Engels was on his way back to Manchester to recommence working in his father’s company. The two teamed up for good in Paris two years later, in 1844.

In the same year of 1841, Ludwig Feuerbach published his “Essence of Christianity” of which Engels later said: “…the spell was broken; the "system" was exploded and cast aside ... one must have experienced the liberating effect of this book to get an idea of it. Enthusiasm was general.” We will look next week at the book, Ludwig Feuerbach and the end of German Classical Philosophy, which Engels wrote forty-five years later, in 1886, about the effect of Feuerbach’s intervention.

F W J Schelling had been a colleague and rival of Hegel’s, and had struggled in the great man’s shade. In 1841, at the age of 66, Schelling was made a Prussian privy councillor and member of the Berlin Academy, with the right to give lectures at the university, and an instruction to do so.

Hegel’s philosophy had long been the pride of the Prussian establishment, but it had turned out to be potential weapon in the hands of the proletarian class then growing with the spread of capitalism in Germany. In Berlin philosophical uproar had begun involving the “Young Hegelians”, Feuerbach, Marx, Engels and others. The revolutions of 1848 were a few years away.

Schelling was given an instruction to debunk Hegel. His lectures attracted a sensationally distinguished audience, which included Engels, who said: "It will be our business to follow the course of his [Schelling's] thinking and to shield the great man's [Hegel's] grave from abuse. We are not afraid to fight.” Others present were the Russian anarchist Mikhail Bakunin, the Danish theologian Søren Kierkegaard, and the great Swiss humanist historian of the Renaissance, Jacob Burkhardt.

A good account by Andy Blunden of this “world-historic” philosophical event can be found here on MIA.

In 1842, Engels published a work known as “Anti-Schelling”, which includes in its Chapter 5 the following classically dialectical line: “Only that freedom is genuine which contains necessity…”

Engels was 21 when he started writing “Anti-Schelling”. In contrast to Doctor Karl Marx, Engels was at that stage a military cadet who had never been to university (and never did go). Yet he was bold enough to challenge the official state philosopher, in print. The image above is of Engels in 1841, in his military uniform.

In terms of my rough chronology of philosophers in today’s text, this was the situation following Hume, Rousseau and Kant, and when Marx and Engels come in. Seven years prior to the revolutions of 1848, where the proletariat appears for the first time as a crucial revolutionary subject of history, this was the moment when philosophy split into its subsequent fragments, of which the contending philosophical schools of today are the direct successors.


Further (optional) reading

Previous main Communist University posts:
Channel [members]
Course Archive
CU Africa [229]
CU [3146]

Courses completed in 2010 to date:
March - June

January - March
3 days
2-4 June
March - June

January – March


Post a Comment

Post a Comment